5 Best Shakeology Alternatives to Buy (Budget-Friendly and Delicious)

Pinterest Hidden Image Pinterest Hidden Image

I have had a lot of Instagram DMs over the past few months looking for alternatives to Shakeology, and I thought it was time to write a post. Here are my favorite Shakeology substitutions that are budget-friendly and full of flavor!

shakeology alternatives pinterest image Pin

Randa Nutrition Favicon Pin

Save This Recipe!

Enter your email below & I’ll send it straight to your inbox. Plus you’ll get great new recipes every week!


Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links for your convenience. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

fast track nutrition macros Pin

Grab your Free copy

Fast Track Your Nutrition with Macros

Learn the simple steps to improve your diet without diets and deprivation. 

Shakeology Alternatives

To make it easy for you to read this, the majority of the products shared on this blog post will be available from Amazon since I know both Canadians and Americans have access to this.

I will also provide notes on if I personally tried the product being shared or not, plus my personal and professional thoughts.

As time goes on, I will update the list with more Shakeology alternatives.

I would also love to know what you use instead of Shakeology, let me know in the comments.

What is Shakeology?

Shakeology is a popular meal replacement shake sold through Beachbody and their Independent Beachbody Coaches. The claims are it’s a superfood shake to curb your cravings and aid weight loss.

It is a MLM product and that can rub a lot of people the wrong way as it typically adds up the cost and brings on the pressure of purchasing from friends, family, and DMs from total strangers (which we all hate).

I’m going to say this first: I don’t think it’s a bad product. However, I do believe it’s expensive and there are alternatives out there that are at a lower price point.

In all honesty and transparency, I like the company. I used to purchase the products and enjoyed them but I no longer do.

The cost just wasn’t worth it and I know that I can get healthy supplements elsewhere. I used to do the workouts on Beachbody on Demand, but since then I’ve moved on to free workouts from Caroline Girvan and the Peloton App (you can get 60 days for free here – not sponsored).

I find I’m more than happy with a protein shake that is more cost-effective and isn’t doused in “superfood” marketing.

Related: How many calories are burned doing MBF and MBFA and calories burned doing 9 Week Control Freak.

At the time of writing this, the cost is $155 + shipping for Canadians (and roughly $130 for Americans) if you’re not a coach. Coaches get 25%, which is still pricey!

Can you buy Shakeology on Amazon?

Yes, but I wouldn’t. Beachbody doesn’t sell it on Amazon.

There are resellers that have the price jacked up. If you’re adamant about buying it, you won’t be getting the best deal and you don’t know if it’s expired.

Alternatives to Shakeology

Let’s get this list started, here are some of the best Shakeology alternatives.

  • Are they the same? No.
  • Is that a bad thing? Also, no. A lot of brands have proprietary blends where we don’t know the exact amount of ingredients being used. So it’s common to be sucked into marketing with all this health washing with terms like “superfoods” and other promises.
  • Will I still lose weight? Weight loss is about calorie deficit, not special ingredients. You don’t need any specific food or ingredient to lose weight. If you want help with weight loss you can calculate your needs with the Manage Your Macros calculator (use code MACROS50 to save $50).
  • Am I calling any of these companies liars? No. But it’s something I want you to keep in mind. They are in the business of selling you a product. I’m in the business of helping you find something that works for you, your budget, and your lifestyle.
  • No one should ever feel ashamed because they can’t afford a supplement or guilted into buying because they’re scared you won’t get the results they desire (untrue). You can and will find something that works for you and your budget. All of these protein powders and meal replacements are similar to Shakeology and are mostly plant-based (or vegan).

Garden of Life Raw Organic Protein and Greens

I bought this one a few times. I found the chocolate to be tasty, especially when it’s blended with fruit.

That being said I was able to drink it with just water too. The greens also add some extra vitamins and minerals too.

It was organic brown rice protein, pea protein, chia, navy beans, lentil beans, and garbanzo beans. The greens contain alfalfa juice, spinach, kale, broccoli, carrots, and beets.

An added bonus is their enzyme blend and probiotics.

Orgain Organic Protein and Superfoods

In many health and fitness groups, this protein powder pops up when someone asks for recommendations. I was told the texture is amazing and it’s a gluten free and low calorie alternative.

I personally haven’t tried it yet, but with over 20,000 ratings at a 4.5 star average, I’d say it’s a pretty good Shakeology substitute.

It has 21 grams of protein in each scoop (pea, brown rice, and chia) and no artificial sweeteners.


I share Nuzest on Instagram often. They’re a supplement company that I purchase protein powders from often and they’re delicious and have pretty decent ingredients. It’s a protein powder, it doesn’t have dehydrated veggies or anything in it but it’s a great option for post-workout fuel.

Use code RANDA for 10% off.

Vega Protein and Greens

I have to be honest, I’m not a big of this one. The taste doesn’t sit well with me but so many others love it, and I wanted to include it. Plus the price is good and it’s the most common of the Shakeology alternatives that I see people using.

The All in One formula includes probiotics, has 6 grams of fiber, and comes in a French vanilla or chocolate flavor.

310 Shake

This is another meal replacement shake I haven’t tried, but I see a lot of people swearing by this brand.

It has probiotics, digestive enzymes (helps with digestion), and is plant based. It does have adaptogens added to its blend in addition to fiber and superfoods.

The protein blend includes pea protein, brown rice, and pumpkin (soy free). It has 15 grams of protein (not high protein content but not bad).

310 Shake is the closest I have seen to Shakeology (protein and carb counts are similar), it’s a great dupe.

Healthy Smoothie Recipes

I personally use whey protein powders and add my own ingredients to supercharge them with added nutrients (like chia seed, fruit and a veggie like spinach or kale), here are a few of my favorites:

If you’re looking for a protein supplement, you can get a high-quality one from brands like Legion, Quest, Naked Nutrition, and MyProtein.

What are your favorite alternatives for Shakeology? Let me know what you use in the comments.


manage your macros macros calculator Pin

Ready to calculate your macros in seconds?

Stop guessing and flip-flopping between diets.  Finally have a roadmap with this proven method!

This spreadsheet makes figuring out your macros, a piece of cake.

shakeology substitutions pinterest image Pin

Similar Posts


  1. Thank you for sharing these. I’ve been looking for a Shakeology alternative because I just can’t afford it. I love Shakelolgy, just wish it had a much smaller price tag.

  2. I have tried several of those myself in there find some of them to be extremely disgusting. I have been drinking shakeology now since 2016 and it has changed my life. I would never go back to drinking any of the other stuff. And prior to trying those other things I have been drinking shakes since I was a child because my dad was a bodybuilder so I know a little bit about this stuff.

    1. I’m so happy you find it works for you and you like the taste. There is nothing wrong with the product, aside from the cost. I’ve been asked by clients for more affordable options so wanted to share 🙂 Have a great day!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.